Official comments on the First Round Signatures should be submitted using the "Submit Comment" link for the appropriate algorithm. Comments from the pqc-forum Google group subscribers will also be forwarded to the pqc-forum Google group list. We will periodically post and update the comments received to the appropriate algorithm.
All relevant comments will be posted in their entirety and should not include PII information in the body of the email message.
Please refrain from using OFFICIAL COMMENT to ask administrative questions, which should be sent to pqc-comments@nist.gov
| Algorithm | Algorithm Information | Submitters | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|
| Enhanced pqsigRM | Specification IP Statements Zip file (50 MB) Website |
Jinkyu Cho Jong-Seon No Yongwoo Lee Young-Sik Kim Zahyun Koo |
Submit Comment |
| FuLeeca | Specification IP Statements Zip file (7 MB) Website |
Stefan Ritterhoff Sebastian Bitzer Patrick Karl Georg Maringer Thomas Schamberger Jonas Schupp Georg Sigl Antonia Wachter-Zeh Violetta Weger |
Submit Comment |
| LESS Linear Equivalence Signature Scheme |
Specification IP Statements Zip file (2 MB) |
Marco Baldi Alessandro Barenghi Luke Beckwith Jean-François Biasse Andre Esser Kris Gaj Kamyar Mohajerani Gerardo Pelosi Edoardo Persichetti Markku-Juhani O. Saarinen Paolo Santini Robert Wallace |
Submit Comment |
| MEDS Matrix Equivalence Digital Signature |
Specification |
Tung Chou Ruben Niederhagen Edoardo Persichetti Lars Ran Tovohery Hajatiana Randrianarisoa Krijn Reijnders Simona Samardjiska Monika Trimoska |
Submit Comment |
| Wave | Specification IP Statements Zip file (4 MB) KAT Files (see website) |
Gustavo Banegas Kévin Carrier André Chailloux Alain Couvreur Thomas Debris-Alazard Philippe Gaborit Pierre Karpman Johanna Loyer Ruben Niederhagen Nicolas Sendrier Benjamin Smith Jean-Pierre Tillich |
Submit Comment |
| Algorithm | Algorithm Information | Submitters | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|
| SQIsign | Specification IP Statements Zip file (14 MB) Website |
Jorge Chavez-Saab Maria Corte-Real Santos Luca De Feo Jonathan Komada Eriksen Basil Hess David Kohel Antonin Leroux Patrick Longa Michael Meyer Lorenz Panny Sikhar Patranabis Christophe Petit Francisco Rodríguez Henríquez Sina Schaeffler Benjamin Wesolowski |
Submit Comment |
| Algorithm | Algorithm Information | Submitters | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|
| EagleSign | Specification IP Statements Zip file (9 MB) Website |
Djiby Sow Abiodoun Clement Hounkpevi Sidoine Djimnaibeye Michel Seck |
Submit Comment |
| EHTv3 and EHTv4 | Specification IP Statements Zip file (73 MB) Website |
Igor Semaev Martin Feussner |
Submit Comment |
| HAETAE | Specification IP Statements Zip file (17 MB) Website |
Jung Hee Cheon Hyeongmin Choe Julien Devevey Tim Güneysu Dongyeon Hong Markus Krausz Georg Land Junbum Shin Damien Stehlé MinJune Yi |
Submit Comment |
| HAWK | Specification IP Statements Zip file (6 MB) Website |
Joppe W. Bos Olivier Bronchain Léo Ducas Serge Fehr Yu-Hsuan Huang Thomas Pornin Eamonn W. Postlethwaite Thomas Prest Ludo N. Pulles Wessel van Woerden |
Submit Comment |
| HuFu Hash-and-Sign Signatures From Powerful Gadgets |
Specification IP Statements Zip file (164 MB) KAT Files (website) |
Yang Yu Huiwen Jia Leibo Li Delong Ran Zhiyuan Qiu Shiduo Zhang Xiuhan Lin Xiaoyun Wang |
Submit Comment |
| Raccoon | Specification IP Statements Zip file (89 MB) |
Rafael del Pino Thomas Espitau Shuichi Katsumata Mary Maller Fabrice Mouhartem Thomas Prest Mélissa Rossi Markku-Juhani Saarinen |
Submit Comment |
| SQUIRRELS Square Unstructured Integer Euclidean Lattice Signature |
Specification |
Thomas Espitau Guilhem Niot Chao Sun Mehdi Tibouchi |
Submit Comment |
| Algorithm | Algorithm Information | Submitters | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|
| CROSS Codes and Restricted Objects Signature Scheme |
Specification IP Statements Zip file (11 MB) Website |
Marco Baldi Alessandro Barenghi Sebastian Bitzer Patrick Karl Felice Manganiello Alessio Pavoni Gerardo Pelosi Paolo Santini Jonas Schupp Freeman Slaughter Antonia Wachter-Zeh Violetta Weger |
Submit Comment |
| MIRA | Specification IP Statements Zip file (18 MB) Website |
Nicolas Aragon Magali Bardet Loïc Bidoux Jesús-Javier Chi-Domínguez Victor Dyseryn Thibauld Feneuil Philippe Gaborit Romaric Neveu Matthieu Rivain Jean-Pierre Tillich |
Submit Comment |
| MiRitH MinRank in the Head |
Specification IP Statements Zip file (85 MB) Website |
Gora Adj Luis Rivera-Zamarripa Javier Verbel Emanuele Bellini Stefano Barbero Andre Esser Carlo Sanna Floyd Zweydinger |
Submit Comment |
| MQOM MQ on my Mind |
Specification IP Statements Zip file (30 MB) Website |
Thibauld Feneuil Matthieu Rivain |
Submit Comment |
| PERK | Specification IP Statements Zip file (37 MB) Website |
Najwa Aaraj Slim Bettaieb Loïc Bidoux Alessandro Budroni Victor Dyseryn Andre Esser Philippe Gaborit Mukul Kulkarni Victor Mateu Marco Palumbi Lucas Perin Jean-Pierre Tillich |
Submit Comment |
| RYDE | Specification IP Statements Zip file (18 MB) Website |
Nicolas Aragon Magali Bardet Loïc Bidoux Jesús-Javier Chi-Domínguez Victor Dyseryn Thibauld Feneuil Philippe Gaborit Antoine Joux Matthieu Rivain Jean-Pierre Tillich Adrien Vinçotte |
Submit Comment |
| SDitH Syndrome Decoding in the Head |
Specification IP Statements Zip file (54 MB) Website |
Carlos Aguilar Melchor Thibauld Feneuil Nicolas Gama Shay Gueron James Howe David Joseph Antoine Joux Edoardo Persichetti Tovohery H. Randrianarisoa Matthieu Rivain Dongze Yue |
Submit Comment |
| Algorithm | Algorithm Information | Submitters | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3WISE | Specification IP Statements Zip file (9 MB) KAT_128 & 192 (75 MB) KAT_256 (190 MB) Website |
Borja Gómez Rodríguez |
Submit Comment |
| Biscuit | Specification IP Statements Zip file (14 MB) Website |
Luk Bettale Delaram Kahrobaei Ludovic Perret Javier Verbel |
Submit Comment |
| DME-Sign | Specification IP Statements Zip file (9 MB) Website |
Ignacio Luengo Martín Avendaño |
Submit Comment |
| HPPC Hidden Product of Polynomial Composition |
Specification IP Statements Zip file (190 MB) Website |
Borja Gómez Rodríguez |
Submit Comment |
| MAYO | Specification IP Statements Zip file (19 MB) |
Ward Beullens Fabio Campos Sofía Celi Basil Hess Matthias J. Kannwischer |
Submit Comment |
| PROV PRovable unbalanced Oil and Vinegar |
Specification IP Statements Zip file (<1 MB) KAT files (see website) |
Louis Goubin Benoît Cogliati Jean-Charles Faugère Pierre-Alain Fouque Robin Larrieu Gilles Macario-Rat Brice Minaud Jacques Patarin |
Submit Comment |
| QR-UOV |
Specification |
Hiroki Furue Yasuhiko Ikematsu Fumitaka Hoshino Tsuyoshi Takagi Kan Yasuda Toshiyuki Miyazawa Tsunekazu Saito Akira Nagai |
Submit Comment |
| SNOVA | Specification IP Statements Zip file (3 MB) KAT Files 1 (66 MB) KAT Files 2 (191 MB) |
Lih-Chung Wang Chun-Yen Chou Jintai Ding Yen-Liang Kuan Ming-Siou Li Bo-Shu Tseng Po-En Tseng Chia-Chun Wang |
Submit Comment |
| TUOV Triangular Unbalanced Oil and Vinegar |
Specification IP Statements Zip file (6 MB) |
Jintai Ding Boru Gong Hao Guo Xiaoou He Yi Jin Yuansheng Pan Dieter Schmidt Chengdong Tao Danli Xie Bo-Yin Yang Ziyu Zhao |
Submit Comment |
| UOV Unbalanced Oil and Vinegar |
Specification IP Statements Zip file (8 MB) |
Ward Beullens Ming-Shing Chen Jintai Ding Boru Gong Matthias J. Kannwischer Jacques Patarin Bo-Yuan Peng Dieter Schmidt Cheng-Jhih Shih Chengdong Tao Bo-Yin Yang |
Submit Comment |
| VOX | Specification IP Statements Zip file (64 MB) |
Jacques Patarin Benoît Cogliati Jean-Charles Faugère Pierre-Alain Fouque Louis Goubin Robin Larrieu Gilles Macario-Rat Brice Minaud |
Submit Comment |
| Algorithm | Algorithm Information | Submitters | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|
| AIMer | Specification IP Statements Zip file (34 MB) |
Seongkwang Kim Jihoon Cho Mingyu Cho Jincheol Ha Jihoon Kwon Byeonghak Lee Joohee Lee Jooyoung Lee Sangyub Lee Dukjae Moon Mincheol Son Hyojin Yoon |
Submit Comment |
| Ascon-Sign | Specification IP Statements Zip file (9 MB) Website |
Vikas Srivastava Naina Gupta Arpan Jati Anubhab Baksi Jakub Breier Anupam Chattopadhyay Sumit Kumar Debnath Xiaolu Hou |
Submit Comment |
| FAEST | Specification IP Statements Zip file (30 MB) Website |
Carsten Baum Lennart Braun Cyprien Delpech de Saint Guilhem Michael Klooß Christian Majenz Shibam Mukherjee Emmanuela Orsini Sebastian Ramacher Christian Rechberger Lawrence Roy Peter Scholl |
Submit Comment |
| SPHINCS-alpha | Specification IP Statements Zip file (50 MB) Website |
Yu Yu Hongrui Cui Kaiyi Zhang |
Submit Comment |
| Algorithm | Algorithm Information | Submitters | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|
| ALTEQ | Specification IP Statements Zip file (2 MB) KAT_1 (34 MB) KAT_2 (210 MB) KAT_3 (234 MB) Website |
Markus Bläser Dung Hoang Duong Anand Kumar Narayanan Thomas Plantard Youming Qiao Arnaud Sipasseuth Gang Tang |
Submit Comment |
| eMLE-Sig 2.0 Embedded Multilayer Equations with Heavy Layer Randomization |
Specification IP Statements Zip file (7 MB) Website |
Dongxi Liu Raymond K. Zhao |
Submit Comment |
| KAZ-SIGN Kriptografi Atasi Zarah |
Specification IP Statements Zip file (10 MB) Website |
Muhammad Rezal Kamel Ariffin Nur Azman Abu Terry Lau Shue Chien Zahari Mahad Amir Hamzah Abd Ghafar Nurul Amiera Sakinah Abdul Jamal |
Submit Comment |
| Preon | Specification IP Statements Zip file (21 MB) KAT_128 (55 MB) KAT_192 (117 MB) KAT_256 (187 MB) Website |
Ming-Shing Chen Yu-Shian Chen Chen-Mou Cheng Shiuan Fu Wei-Chih Hong Jen-Hsuan Hsiang Sheng-Te Hu Po-Chun Kuo Wei-Bin Lee Feng-Hao Liu Justin Thaler |
Submit Comment |
| Xifrat1-Sign.I | Specification IP Statements Zip file (2 MB) Website |
Jianfang "Danny" Niu Daniel Enrique Náger Piazuelo |
Submit Comment |
Security and Privacy: digital signatures, post-quantum cryptography